Your development decision
Treat small fibre balls and surface wear as distinct questions, using appropriate reports and actual garment observations.
Distinguish the property
Pilling concerns small fibre balls forming at the surface; abrasion concerns wear under rubbing. They can appear together but are not the same result. Ask which property a proposed claim or report actually addresses.
Keep the reference context
Fibre, yarn, construction and finish all contribute to the cloth being assessed. A category or composition statement cannot establish the performance value of an actual sample. Confirm the candidate and its current finish.
Choose relevant wear locations
Observe seat, elbows, cuffs, pocket edges and contact from straps or other layers. Record activity and duration. These garment observations give useful context but are not an automatic substitute for a specified test.
Compare reports on the same basis
Review method, conditions, rating, sample identity, colour and report date. Different methods or conditions may answer different questions. Ask the technical team how the result relates to the buyer requirement before comparing numbers.
Keep missing evidence open
If no relevant report is available, request testing or record the point as unresolved. Do not infer zero pilling from a photograph. Retain not checked until an observation or applicable result exists.
Brief the requirement precisely
Write the intended garment, relevant contact areas and specified buyer test if known. Ask Fred which evidence can accompany the proposed reference. Keep acceptable appearance and formal test acceptance as clearly defined, separate decisions.
A practical development example
A team has a pilling report and wants to approve abrasion resistance. First check which property and method the report covers. Keep the pilling evidence in its own field and request the relevant abrasion evidence if required. Add garment rubbing observations as context without inventing a laboratory rating.
Working review record
Scroll the table horizontally on small screens.
| Review point | What to record | Next decision |
|---|---|---|
| Surface-ball formation or cloth wear | Record the actual value, conditions and source | Keep this point open until reviewed |
| Actual garment rubbing location | Record the actual value, conditions and source | Keep this point open until reviewed |
| Report method and conditions | Record the actual value, conditions and source | Keep this point open until reviewed |
| Tested colour and sample version | Record the actual value, conditions and source | Keep this point open until reviewed |
Before the next sample round
- Surface-ball formation or cloth wear
- Actual garment rubbing location
- Report method and conditions
- Tested colour and sample version
- Record the reviewer, date and next action